Wisconsin Supreme Court Expands Use of Expert Testimony in Sexual Assault Trials

The Wisconsin Supreme Court recently issued a decision that addressed the use of expert testimony in child sexual assault trials. Specifically, the Supreme Court unanimously permitted expert witnesses to address the frequency of false reports of child sexual abuse.

Background of State v. Molde

In the case of State v. Molde, a 13-year-old girl, identified by the pseudonym “Lauren,” reported after an attempted suicide that her father, defendant Jobert Molde, had sexually assaulted her when she was seven or eight years old.

At trial, the credibility of Lauren’s recorded forensic interview and trial testimony became a key issue. The state presented expert testimony from Dr. Alice Swenson, who supervised Lauren’s forensic interview. After Dr. Swenson testified, a juror submitted a question asking, “How frequent is it for children to make up a story of sexual abuse?” Dr. Swenson testified that, “False disclosures are extraordinarily rare…one percent of all disclosures are false disclosures.”

After Molde’s conviction, he filed a motion for postconviction relief, arguing that his trial counsel was ineffective for failing to object to Dr. Swenson’s testimony as impermissible vouching for Lauren’s credibility. Although the trial court denied the motion because Dr. Swenson did not comment explicitly on Lauren’s credibility, the intermediate appeals court cited its precedent, which held that expert testimony regarding the frequency of false reports of sexual abuse from children constituted impermissible vouching.

What the Ruling Means

Molde appealed to the Wisconsin Supreme Court, which reversed the intermediate appellate court’s decision and overturned its precedent. The Supreme Court held that “statistical evidence alone is precisely the kind of generalized evidence that might assist the jury” because such evidence did not opine as to whether the victim fell into the category of truthful or untruthful witnesses.

The Supreme Court noted that such testimony left the jury to assess the credibility of the expert’s testimony and statistical evidence. The court clarified that only expert testimony opining on the credibility of a specific witness violated evidentiary rules. The court also noted that other rules of evidence applied to expert testimony regarding statistical rates of truthfulness of sexual assault victims, including rules regarding admissibility, expert qualifications, and methodology.

How the Case Can Affect Sexual Assault Trials

Molde allows parties to present generalized expert testimony providing statistical evidence about the rates of false reports or testimony in sexual assault cases if an expert does not opine on the credibility of a specific victim or witness. However, such expert testimony remains subject to basic admissibility requirements. As a result, parties may need to prepare to challenge such expert testimony when the opposing side offers an expert who opines on rates of false sexual assault reports.

Takeaways for Defendants and Their Counsel

The ability for prosecutors to present expert testimony on the low prevalence of false reporting in sexual assault cases makes it critical for defendants to secure highly skilled legal counsel. Defense attorneys must prepare cases that challenge such expert testimony, either through vigorous cross-examination to undermine the expert’s credibility or by presenting competing experts who can provide a more persuasive analysis of available data.

Furthermore, defendants and defense counsel must remain vigilant to ensure that expert testimony on the low rates of false sexual assault claims does not stray into improper vouching for victims’ credibility.

Contact a Criminal Defense Lawyer Today

If you’ve been arrested for sexual assault, you need experienced legal representation that can work with the complex facts and issues in your case. Contact Ahmad & Associates today for a confidential consultation with a criminal defense attorney. Let’s discuss the challenges you may face in your prosecution and review your options for pursuing a favorable resolution to your charges.

Archives
Archives