Felonies are a serious crime in Wisconsin, and a felony conviction can carry several years in prison and expensive fines. However, what if you have previous convictions on your record? Do previous convictions make a difference in Wisconsin felony cases?
The answer is: it depends. Prior convictions may not be admissible evidence in current felony criminal trials, but they can affect final sentencing and witness credibility during a trial. Talk to a criminal defense attorney if you have more questions about the role that prior convictions can play in criminal cases.
Prior Convictions and Wisconsin’s Three Strike Rule
Prior convictions are most relevant when determining the sentence of subsequent felony offenses. In most cases, a prior felony conviction can result in harsher criminal penalties for a new felony crime. This penalty is longer than it would be if you didn’t have a previous conviction. For instance, if you have a previous conviction, a crime that carries five years could instead carry seven years or more.
Wisconsin also has what’s called a “three-strike” law. According to the three-strike law, if someone is convicted of three or more violent felony crimes, they can face a sentence of 25 years to life in prison with no possibility of parole. Felony crimes in Wisconsin that count towards this three-strikes limit include:
- Homicide or manslaughter
- Sexual assault
- Felony drug crimes
- Kidnapping
- Carjacking
- Arson
- Armed robbery or burglary
A single criminal event involving multiple crimes can result in multiple convictions that count toward the three-strike limit. For instance, if someone commits armed robbery and carjacking at the same time, those crimes would count as two separate felonies under Wisconsin’s three-strike rule.
Can Prior Convictions Count as Evidence in Criminal Trials?
Some may worry that prior convictions will be brought up as evidence of guilt in a new criminal trial. Fortunately, prior convictions are not admissible as evidence in criminal trials. For example, the prosecution cannot bring up a prior assault conviction as evidence for the accused’s guilt in an unrelated theft charge. The simple fact that the accused once committed a crime in the past has no bearing on current criminal charges.
However, prior convictions can factor into judgments of a witness’s credibility or character during a criminal trial. This includes when the accused themselves are called as witnesses. The law generally allows courts to ask whether a given witness has committed a crime for the purposes of evaluating their trustworthiness on the stand.
Not all criminal convictions are allowed to be considered, though. Specifically, the court might dismiss evidence of a witness’s criminal conviction when accepting it runs the risk of creating “unfair prejudice” against them (Wis. Stat. 906.09). Whether or not the probative value of the evidence outweighs the risk of creating unfair prejudice depends on:
- Length of time since the crime occurred
- Witness’s current and recent conduct/behavior
- The severity of the previous crime
- Rehabilitative efforts and pardons
- The total number of previous convictions
- Whether the previous conviction involved dishonesty or false statements
- Other factors the court deems relevant
Criminal Defense Attorneys Serving Wisconsin
A prior conviction can have a massive effect on your criminal trial, so it’s important to have an attorney who can meet the challenges. Attorney Aneeq Ahmad has an established track record of successfully managing felony cases in Wisconsin and can help those with prior convictions avoid the worst consequences of a criminal charge. Don’t leave your freedoms and liberty to chance – choose Ahmad & Associates instead. Contact our firm online or call today to schedule a consultation with a criminal defense attorney in Wisconsin.